Source for VMEbus, PMC Modules, CompactPCI, Single Board Computers, Rackmount Servers, and Rackmount Chassis

Home
Up
Search
Industrial Products

RAID RAS
RAID Management
RAID Performance
RAID Cost
RAID Feature Summary
RAID Glossary
MTBF

Hardware- or Software-Based RAID
Which Solution is Best for You?


Management


With the explosion of on-line data, the cost of managing that data has escalated as well. For every dollar spent on initial storage purchase, various estimates calculate that another $5 to $7 is spent managing the storage. These figures include the cost of installing, configuring, monitoring, and optimizing the on-line storage for performance, as well as backing up, restoring, and archiving the data. For smaller businesses and IT sites who can't afford a dedicated or sophisticated IT staff but need to protect their valuable data, storage management ease of use is of paramount importance.

Let's examine the manageability issue from two aspects: how easy is it install and configure a software or hardware-based RAID, and how easy is it to monitor and proactively manage the RAID installation.


Installing RAID [top of page]

The bottom line on comparing installation procedures for a software- or hardware-based RAID solution is that the order of installation steps is simply different. With software-based RAID such as Microsoft Windows NT, you install the card/server hardware, load the operating system software on a single disk drive, run the array program, and then configure the RAID array. With hardware-based RAID, you install the card/server hardware, configure your RAID arrays, and load the operating system on one of the arrays. You then have the option to install more sophisticated RAID management software such as Adaptec®'s CI/O Management Software™ to take advantage of features such as remote monitoring and hot spares with automatic recovery.


Configuring RAID [top of page]

There can be significant differences between RAID solutions in both the ease of configuring arrays and the degree to which you can tune your arrays for optimum performance or functionality. Does the solution offer a streamlined configuration "wizard" that uses default settings to help first-time users to get up and running quickly? For more sophisticated users, advanced features like variable stripe depths, spare allocation (either dedicated or global) and setting drive reconstruction priorities (low/medium/high) become important differentiators.

Windows NT RAID software uses one stripe depth - 64 kB, based on research that concludes most applications achieve optimal performance with stripe depths between 64 kB and 128 kB. Windows NT does not offer spare allocation because failed drives are manually replaced by the system manager. In contrast, hardware-based RAID solutions typically offer a variety of stripe depth options, such as 8, 16, 32, 64 and 128 kB. More sophisticated hardware solutions also offer spare allocation and priority settings on drive reconstruction.


Managing RAID [top of page]

As discussed in the previous section on serviceability, some of the key differences in managing software- and hardware-based RAID solutions center on the ease of identifying and reporting errors. Hardware-based solutions typically offer more sophisticated management software features such as alerts color-coded by severity, e-mail, fax or pager notification of errors, and remote management of multiple RAID installations.

But this is just the beginning. Graphical user interfaces (GUIs) that employ a Windows-like look and feel with pop-down menus, property tabs, physical and logical views in drill-down Windows_ Explorer-type tree structures, and detailed views can make a huge difference in the ease of managing your storage.

Not all RAID solutions offer GUIs. Unlike software-based solutions, hardware-based RAID solutions allow monitoring and management of RAID configurations on multiple operating systems such as Windows NT and Novell Netware. The ability of hardware-based solutions to remotely manage RAID storage means that you can initialize new arrays and reactivate offline arrays without ever leaving your desk.

More sophisticated hardware-based RAID management implementations support preventive maintenance activities such as monitoring card, drive and enclosure fan and temperature status but also testing hot spares, verifying parity information, and reconstructing the information on a failed drive. Some even allow you to schedule these activities, thus eliminating the need for manual intervention and minimizing impact on server performance. Another distinguishing feature among RAID management implementations is the ability to poll servers, networks and non-RAID configurations, so that downtime conditions are more quickly detected and isolated.


[contents] [previous] [next]
 

An Industrial Partner 1999-2002. All rights reserved.


CompactPCI, Embedded SBCs, Flat panel Displays, Industrial Chassis, IndustrialPC Peripherals, Industrial Power Supplies, Backplanes, Single Board Computers, Rackmount Servers, Network Communication, Open Frame Panel Computer, PC/104, Flash Disk, CTI, RAID Industrial Products CompactPCI, Embedded SBCs, Flat panel Displays, Industrial Chassis, IndustrialPC Peripherals, Industrial Power Supplies, Backplanes, Single Board Computers, Rackmount Servers, Network Communication, Open Frame Panel Computer, PC/104, Flash Disk, CTI, RAID E-Mail

VoxTechnologies Corp. - Industrial Computer Leader
Tel:
1-972-234-4343 Fax: 1-972-234-4295 Toll-Free:1-888-568-6224

For over a decade, VoxTechnologies has been a leading source of industrial computers and complete system products for the O.E.M. and Systems Integrator. Our primary goal is to provide a solution source for engineers that have the challenging task of interfacing and controlling the real world.

 
Telephone: 1-972-234-4343 General Info: info@voxtechnologies.com Sales Info: sales@voxtechnologies.com
 
We accept all major credit cards
Send mail to webmaster@voxtechnologies.com with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 1999 VoxTechnologies Corporation- An Industrial Partner
Last modified: June 20, 2002